Imagine, if you will. You have been house hunting for almost a year and are finally in escrow on a property that you love. It feels right, and you couldn’t be happier. You follow your agent’s advice and have a professional home inspection. You are expecting the inspector to come back praising you for choosing such a wonderful property, only to get a long report telling you that your dream home is practically falling apart. Now what do you do?
I’ll explain.
Looking at an “Ugly” Home Inspection Report
Most people feel at least a little disappointed after reviewing a home inspection report. Buyers often feel let down or even frightened. Sellers can get defensive and may even become concerned that the buyer is just trying to negotiate a new deal.
If you think about it, a professional inspector is essentially paid by the buyer to criticize a property that the buyer feels strongly enough to buy. The inspector is trained to look for defects and things that could potentially go wrong. They always find something. It’s their job.
Some Perspective on Home Inspections
It is important to keep home inspections in perspective. A home inspection is not some kind of test that a property passes or fails. It’s just a report that points out defects and documents the condition of a property. It is prepared by a neutral third party who has conducted a thorough inspection.
The home inspector is a trained professional who inspects a property to point out defects, deficiencies, and potential problems. They have general knowledge and are not experts in any specific trade. Home inspectors are not electricians, roofers, or foundation experts. They point out things that might be of concern and let everyone else figure it out.
Home inspectors don’t want anyone to come back to them saying they missed something that should have been found. Keep this in mind when reviewing a home inspection.
Buyers need to figure out if they need to conduct additional inspections, make repair requests, and determine if they want to proceed with the transaction. It is a healthy step in the home buying process.
How Should a Buyer Respond to an “Ugly” Inspection Report?
Buyers need to decide what really matters and what is important to them when reviewing the report. Very rarely will something be discovered during a home inspection that cannot be figured out. Buyers need to review the report and determine if they are fine moving forward with the purchase and what, if anything, they should request from the seller.
It is pretty much expected that buyers will make some requests of the seller. They typically request some repairs to be made during the escrow period or ask for a credit instead of repairs. However, except for a few statutory requirements like smoke detectors, the seller is not obligated to make any repairs. If the buyer does not find the seller’s response acceptable, the buyer has the option of walking away from the deal. In almost all cases, the buyer’s “good faith” deposit will be returned in full if they don’t proceed due to a home inspection.
What Kind of Repairs Should a Buyer Request?
Buyers should limit requests to things discovered during the home inspection. Don’t ask for a “flooring credit” if the worn-out carpet was apparent at the time the offer was written. If the flooring is visibly worn out and you want a flooring credit, ask for it when making your offer.
If an active leak is found under the house or the air conditioning is discovered not to work during the home inspection, then it is certainly reasonable to request those repairs. The buyer would not have known about those defects when touring the property, and it is reasonable to assume those items would be working when the offer was written.
Buyers should focus on what is important to them. This often means concentrating on health and safety issues. If the buyer has plans to redo the kitchen and replace all the appliances, then don’t ask for the dishwasher to be fixed. It is wasteful and will detract from things that matter.
Common Mistakes Buyers Make When Requesting Repairs
Three common mistakes buyers make when requesting repairs include:
- Afraid to ask: Some buyers don’t ask for something because they don’t want to lose the deal. A seller can’t cancel just because a buyer requested a repair. If it is reasonable, go ahead and ask.
- Not itemizing the request: Some buyers will just reference the report, essentially asking the sellers to fix everything, which is a sign of a lazy agent. Repairs take time, effort, and are an expense. Take the time to type out an organized and thoughtful request if those items really matter.
- Asking for too much: If a buyer requests too much, they will not be taken seriously. Asking for too much usually backfires. It is a lot harder to say no to a fair and reasonable request than it is to turn down a long wish list.
You may be surprised to see how much a seller will be willing to do if the request is reasonable. Don’t forget that a credit will come from the proceeds through escrow. Sometimes even repairs can be paid for through escrow. Just be reasonable and don’t be afraid to ask.
How Should a Seller Respond to a Request for Repairs?
Sellers should stay open to reasonable buyer repair requests. The buyer is not your adversary. By the time you are in escrow, everyone should have the same goal of a smooth and amicable transaction. Just because a buyer asks for something does not mean that you have to say yes. Don’t forget that if the transaction falls apart due to something discovered during the home inspection, you will have to disclose this material fact to the next buyer.
Common Mistakes Sellers Make When Responding to Repair Requests
Three common mistakes sellers make when handling requests for repairs include:
- Not giving a credit: If the buyer will take a credit instead of the actual repairs, then offer a credit. Buyers will not always agree to a credit, but sometimes it is their preference. A credit is less risky than a repair and prevents any ambiguity about the suitability of the repairs made.
- Committing without knowing: Don’t commit to making any repairs without knowing the fix and what it will cost. Sometimes what may look like a small repair can turn into a big, expensive ordeal, or your idea of a fix might not be the same as the buyer’s.
- Making repairs before contingency removal: Don’t make repairs before contingencies are removed unless they are repairs that you would make even if the deal does not go through.
Having clear communication between the agents before the seller commits to a response can be essential to coming up with the most effective solution. Like any other negotiation, figure out what matters most.
Bottom Line
Most people feel disappointed after reviewing a home inspection. Buyers feel let down, sellers get defensive, and things can fall apart. Remember that home inspectors have general knowledge about a lot of things but are not experts in any specific trade. Inspectors always find multiple issues. Buyers must determine if they want further inspections by specialists and if there are any requests they have for the seller.
Buyers need to focus on what matters, as the seller is usually not obligated to fix anything. However, buyers should not be afraid to make reasonable requests. They need to make an organized list and not ask for too much, or it might backfire.
Sellers should take the buyer’s request seriously. The buyer could walk away, and the seller would need to disclose any new information discovered from the inspection. Sellers should offer credits instead of repairs, when possible. They should be careful not to commit to fixing something without knowing what is involved and not make any repairs before contingencies are removed.
Buyers and sellers should focus on the big picture, stay reasonable and positive. After all, most home inspections can get worked through, even the ugly ones.
For Real Estate Advice
If you are looking for a real estate broker to guide you through the sales process or a reliable property management company to help you handle a rental property in Long Beach, Los Angeles, or Orange County, California, or you are just considering it and have a few questions about real estate, contact the Mike Dunfee Group today! We are happy to help.
Dunfee Real Estate Services, Inc. DRE # 02026232




